Apple Butter Custard Pie

Baking, Dessert | November 19, 2015 | By

With Autumn comes harvesting.  With harvesting comes trips to the orchards.  What is it about grabbing family, friends, or both, and heading out to the Pick Your Own apple orchard?  There’s something so nostalgic about this event for me.  Growing up in Southern Ontario, we had access to amazing farmland and orchards.  For a time, once a year, on a Saturday afternoon, a whole whack of our family and friends would fill up the various cars and vans and head out to the apple orchards near Kingsville, Ontario.  The younger ones would run directly over to the hay bale maze or the petting zoo (okay, us older kids did too!) while the parents (minus a few adults to supervise the kids to make sure they weren’t tormenting the goats and donkeys) wandered over to the rows upon rows of apples, all the varieties imaginable at that time.  

Baskets were filled, and if they got too heavy, you just had to wait for a truck pulling a flatbed to pass by, that you could jump on to and catch a ride back to the main barn.  Ooh- that barn!  Filled with all sorts of goodies: hot apple cider, candied apples, apple fritters, freshly baked pies, bags of apples (if you really didn’t feel like reaching up and picking your own), cornbread… I could just hang out in the barn!

 The day always ended with everyone streaming to one of our homes or farms, and having a bon fire.  And the guys all cooked.  It was the men who would each try to outdo each other with their ‘Mine’s the Hottest Chilli Ever’ contest.  A few of us may have had tears welling up from the crazy amounts of cayenne and dried chillies, but it was so worth it.  We’d each grab a bowl and head out to the bon fire, crackling away.  Bliss.  The best time with friends etched in my mind forever.

The next weekend it was the girls’ turn.  We’d all converge in a few kitchens and bake.  It was the best assembly line work imaginable.  The ones who loved making crusts got to work on the counter, making batches and batches of dough.  The rest were relegated to apple peeling and slicing.  Then we’d put the pies together, some with lattices, some with rounds of pastry on top, and others with streusel toppings.  Ovens were working overtime.  But by the end of that day, everyone went home with a backseat full of pies ready for the freezer (and one to eat right away).

Apple pie is glorious.  So is pumpkin pie.  There is something so earthy, and slightly savoury about a pumpkin pie. But this year, I had to try something new.  I had cooked off some apple butter, and realized how thick it really was once cooled.  Could this not be a substitute for pumpkin puree?  An apple pie in the shape of a pumpkin pie?  Was this going against all that was right?  I went to my trusty Pinterest, and found out that I alas, wasn’t the first to think radically.  I compared various recipes, gleaning input as I went along.  In the end, I decided to pull out my old pumpkin pie recipe and play with it.  And this is the result.  A silky, velvety apple custard pie.  All the spices you expect, but in the smoothest texture.  Have a piece.  Remember, an apple a day keeps the doctor away.

This recipe will vary depending on the apple butter you are using.  I like my butter very thick and rich, dark and spicy.  So I make my own, here.  But if you chose to purchase your apple butter, you may need to adjust the spices and stabilizing cornstarch in the recipe.  If you have ever made a pumpkin pie, you know the texture of the filling you are looking for.  If not, you don’t want the filling too thin. It should still pourable, but not runny at all.

I’ve played with it and I think even improved it.  By adding a touch of spice.  There’s pink peppercorns ground in the batter, and the finished pie is sprinkled with Maldon Sea Salt.  The perfect contrast to the velvety richness of the filling.  Enjoy!

Love Jen.

Apple Butter Custard Pie

Apple Butter Custard Pie

Apple Butter Pie 2

slice of apple pie

Apple Butter Custard Pie
Yields 1
Not your average apple pie. Silky, rich and velvety, a custard pie.
Write a review
Prep Time
15 min
Cook Time
50 min
Prep Time
15 min
Cook Time
50 min
  1. Pastry for 1 9" pie
  2. 1 cup apple butter (see my apple butter recipe post)
  3. 1/2 cup sugar
  4. 3 eggs
  5. 1-2 tbsp of cornstarch (see note below)
  6. 1 1/2 tsp cinnamon
  7. 1/4 tsp ground nutmeg
  8. pinch of salt
  9. pinch of nutmeg
  10. 5 shakes of angostura bitters
  11. 1/8 tsp crushed pink peppercorns
  12. 1 cup cream
  13. Maldon Salt for garnish
  1. Prepare your pastry shell. Crimp as desired. Freeze till for 20 minutes, and filling is completed.
  2. Preheat the oven to 375 F.
  3. Take all of the filling ingredients (except the cream) and mix in a bowl, until well blended. Add cream last and blend well.
  4. Remove pie shell from the freezer. Pour the filling into the shell. Brush the edge with an egg wash (one egg beaten with a tsp of water) Sprinkle edges with turbinado sugar.
  5. Bake in centre of oven, on a baking sheet, for 45-50 minutes, rotating 180 degrees as the edges start to set, at around 30-35 minutes.
  6. Bake until the centre still jiggles very slightly, but the outside edges are completely set.
  7. Set onto a cooling rack. Sprinkle with 1 to 2 tsp Maldon salt.
  8. Cool on a rack until completely cooled.
  9. Serve at room temperature.
  1. The flavour and consistency of this pie will change depending on the apple butter you use. My butter is pretty thick and highly flavoured. So really, the spices you are adding to the pie are to flavour the custard portion. I like my butter thick, so I only need 1-2 tbsp cornstarch. If you are using a store bought butter, the filling may be a tad thinner. In this case I would add an extra tbsp cornstarch. Bottom line, if you have made a pumpkin pie before, you know the consistency you usually get. Aim for the same with this filling.
  2. If you have too much filling for your pie crust, take remainder an put into a ramekin or two and bake off. A lovely little custard!
The Lemon Apron


  1. Leave a Reply

    July 3, 2016

    What kind of pastry did you use? Puff pastry? I live in argentina and don’t have good industrial pastrys. I discovered your blog today and fall in love with it. I’m so looking forward to trying so many recipes. Congratulations and thank you for sharing!

    • Leave a Reply

      July 3, 2016

      Hi Ariadne. I used the recipe for my ‘Perfect Pie Crust’ recipe, you can find it here on the blog. It is just a regular pie crust, not puff pastry or anything commercial. You should be able to find all of the ingredients where you live. Thank you so much for your kind words- I really appreciate them! Have fun cooking and baking 🙂

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>