The Ultimate Caesar Salad, Really

Sides | July 9, 2016 | By

All Hail Caesar.  Salad, that is.  The most misunderstood salad, if ever there was one.  Back in the day it was a spectacle to have prepared table side at all the best restaurants.  The chef (or waiter) would bring out all the ingredients: the egg yolk, the anchovy (or Worcestershire sauce) , the olive oil, the dijon, the lemon juice, garlic.  He would lightly scramble these at the bottom of the salad bowl till they emulsified into the perfect dressing.  Performance art that you could eat.

Then the greens would be tossed over the dressing.  The croutons  would be added.  All would get gently tossed to get that dressing onto all the leaves.  Some parmesan would be shaved over the bowl, and voila, he would then serve you from the bowl with salad tongs.  A lesson in simplicity where the sum is greater than the total of the parts.  Simple ingredients, but when they are the best of the best, a glorious salad.  Eventually bacon started showing up as one more addition.  In my opinion the only good addition worth including.  More on this later.

Then the 80’s happened.  This salad became the height of ubiquitousness.  And it was presented with all sorts of additions: hard boiled eggs, corn, tomatoes, grilled chicken (okay, I get this one) chickpeas, the list goes on.  And the croutons.  Don’t even get me started on those dreaded croutons.  They all seemed to be those hard as concrete, chiseled cubes from a box.  Dry as cardboard, with no flavour.  This became the acceptable norm for the so-called Caesar Salad.

About this time I got the best Caesar Salad dressing ever from a room-mate.  I’m not exagerating.  To this day, I stick with this and it brings the house down.  It is the perfect blend of egg, oil, garlic, lemon and dijon.  There is a bit of parmesan cheese in it as well, for flavour, and a touch of creaminess.  And for those of you who are squeamish and don’t want to add a smidgen of anchovy paste, I totally agree with the Worcestershire sauce as a replacement.

So, dressing, check.  Fresh torn Romaine (Cos) leaves (and if they are small, leave them whole, as how the original salad was presented- the perfect little cups to hold the dressing), check.  A hunk of Parmesan to shave over the finished salad, check.  All that we need are the bacon and croutons.  And for me they are linked.  

To me, bacon is a necessary component of a good Caesar Salad.  It adds a textural and flavour contrast: that touch of smokey saltiness to play off the creamy, tangy, garlicky dressing.  Plus, it’s a bit of protein (fair enough, questionable protein, but a treat of yummy protein nonetheless!)  Sautéing up several rashers of double smoked bacon is such a wondrous thing to do in the kitchen.  The aroma is like nothing else.  And after the finished bacon has been removed from the pan, comes the piece de resistance, my croutons.  Well, they’re not MINE per say.  I’m sure others do the very same thing.  I must have learned it from somewhere.  Don’t ask me where.  Because I’ve been doing it for decades.  And it is what makes this salad so unique. 

Slice off a few thick pieces of sourdough bread.  Slice these into 3/4 inch wide lengths.  Take each length and tear into cubes roughly 3/4 inch large.  The tearing here is important.  The one knife slice is acceptable.  But if you slice crossways, you will get perfect edges all around, and this is a no-no in my books.  It is the rough, jaggedy edges that will make these taste so good.  After you have made enough croutons for your salad (Approximately 1/3 cup per person) lay them out on a plate or baking sheet to dry out a touch.  Do not use old bread for these.  They should not be rock hard.  I use day old bread with perfect results.

After you have removed the bacon from the pan and set it on paper towels to drain, check the pan to see how much bacon fat is left.  If there is more that 1-2 tablespoons, use a spoon or paper towel to blot up the excess.  Into the remaining  hot warm fat (it should cover the bottom of the pan without being an oil spill) sprinkle some dried thyme and oregano, and swirl around.  Into this oil you are going to throw all your croutons.  Pan fry till browned and crunchy, but still soft in the centre.  Each piece will pick up some of the dried herbs, and the flavour of the bacon.  Remove to a paper towel.  These croutons are amazing.  Crunchy exterior, but no fear of cracking a tooth when biting into it.  I don’t know how many times, when I was waiting on tables, I would find a miserable little pile of boxed, rock hard croutons huddling together, when I came to remove the salad plates from a table.  This will never happen with these croutons!  They taste like bacon, accept the dressing graciously, and add the perfect textural compliment to a simple and yet sublime salad.

On hot, summer days, this is often a go-to dinner for us.  Sure, if there is leftover grilled chicken, I will serve it on the side.  But if you make enough salad, and don’t skimp on the bacon, it is a meal unto itself.  Add a glass of wine and call it a night!

You’re welcome!

Love Jen

Caesar Salad

Caesar Salad

Caesar Salad

The Ultimate Caesar Salad, Really
Serves 4
A creamy, tangy, garlicky dressing over a classic salad with the most brilliant croutons ever!
Write a review
Prep Time
20 min
Prep Time
20 min
  1. 2 heads of Romaine hearts (1 large head of Romaine lettuce)
  2. 4-6 slices of double smoked (if possible) bacon
  3. 1 tsp dried thyme
  4. 1 tsp dried oregano
  5. 2-4 thick slices of sourdough bread
  6. hunk of parmesan cheese for shaving over the finished salad
  1. 3/4 cup olive oil
  2. 1/4 cup white wine vinegar
  3. 4-5 cloves of garlic, sliced
  4. 1/4 cup grated parmesan cheese
  5. 1 tsp lemon juice
  6. 1 egg
  7. 1 tsp dijon mustard
  8. 1/8 tsp Worcestershire sauce (or anchovy paste) Both are optional
  1. Wash, dry and tear the larger leaves of Romaine, add to large bowl.
  2. Leave the smaller leaves intact if desired, and add to the bowl.
  3. Take a paper towel and dampen just a touch with cold water. Drape over the bowl and place in the fridge.
  4. Take the slices of sourdough and cut into 3/4" lengths. Take each of these and tear off into 3/4" or so bite sized pieces. Be sure not to use a knife- you want the natural, jagged edges that come with hand tearing. Lay all out on a plate or tray to dry ever so slightly while you work on the dressing and bacon.
  5. Take all the dressing ingredients and place them into a blender. Blend until smooth and creamy. You should not need salt since the parmesan and anchovy paste or Worcestershire sauce add enough already) Set aside.
  6. Place the bacon rashers in a sauté pan and sauté at medium heat until cooked through, but not dry crisp. Remove to a paper towel to drain.
  7. In the pan, remove all but 1-2 tbsp of the bacon fat. There should be enough to coat the entire bottom of the pan without being too deep. Sprinkle the thyme and oregano evenly over the oil.
  8. Raising the heat to medium-high, add the cut up bread to cover the pan in one layer.
  9. Leave to fry for about 40 seconds. Start checking and tossing, so that all sides get equally crisped up. There should be browning, but not burning.
  10. Remove when all are crisped up. This should not take longer than 3-4 minutes total. Remove to paper towel and then a bowl.
  11. Go back to the bacon and tear into bite sized pieces.
  1. Take the greens from the fridge. Add 2/3 of the the croutons and 2/3 of the bacon. Add 2-3 tbsp of dressing per person 1/2 to 3/4 of a cup of the dressing. (this will be determined by how wet or sloppy you like your dressing!) Start off with the 1/2 cup and see what happens after tossing gently but thoroughly.
  2. Place into a serving bowl. Top with the remaining croutons and bacon.
  3. Using a vegetable peeler, shave parmesan cheese over the top of the salad (don't be too skimpy!)
  1. The recipe for this dressing makes about 1.5 cups. It will last a couple of weeks in the fridge.
The Lemon Apron


  1. Leave a Reply

    July 9, 2016

    Perfect! And would go well with my Poke Bowl for a delicious, if culturally demented meal!

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>